The Mandalorian Has a Star Wars Dialogue Problem

Harrison Ford Once famous George Lucas told him about it star Wars The scenario is, “You can write this shit, but you definitely can’t say that!” Suffice it to say, the series has mired in likable, not likable, controversy over bizarre dialogue since its early days. but The MandalorianHis austere manner of conversation makes his privacy even more incongruous.

The series has been light-hearted since the beginning – its hero is Lonely taciturnThe deuteragonist is a non-verbal green child. But as The series progressedHowever, more characters made their way into Din Djarin’s and Grogu’s lives, a toughness cut in the manner of the characters The MandalorianThe world talking to each other is becoming more and more of a problem.

It came to the fore again this week Season Three premiereas Mando does what Mando apparently does best: Wander from planet to planet Hopefully people will explain him like he’s a video game hero picking up side quests. But even after this familiar critique of the show’s narrative structure, something kept coming through in every encounter… characters addressing each other by their full names, no matter who they are. Din Djarin, Griff Karga, Pirate King Jurien Shard, Bo-Katan (though not Bo-Katan Chris, admittedly), many times in the same conversation, people will just pronounce each other’s full name — people who at least know each other, or people who are supposed to be old friends. The closest you can get to a shade of familiarity is the Karga’s welcome cry of “Mando!” Not only does it sound unnatural, but like these names are mentioned almost as trademarks –Longing to get into the wiki entriesor decorated on the goods, as if they are less realistic people and more action figures.

The title wouldn’t be so annoying if it weren’t for its repetition, or if it were the only contradictory thing about it The Mandaloriana dialogue. It rarely feels as though the people in the scene are talking to each other, but it feels like it does in each other, conveying explanatory information as openly and hardly as possible. Those are good actors – look what Pedro Pascal has done in the lead-up to this season The last of us—but it is inherent in the nature of the dialogue itself. It’s cut and simple, and any moments of warmth or familiarity come from little flourishes and offhand remarks — like the way Dean desperately tries to get Grogu to stop hugging robot engineer Anzellan.

It is particularly strange, even with star Wars” Duff Dialogue Historyto get this kind of writing style immediately in woke up from Andor. This series had a different writing and creative team, sure, but it was her natural dialogue that brought the series to life from the get-go, making its characters feel like fully formed beings in the setting. There might be a reason for that Andor You could refer to a strong monologue eg Kino Lowe Prison GatheringAnd Luthon’s diatribe to his informant at the ISBor Funeral speech of acquaintances It also highlights the presentation, for the feeling and lyricism of the dialogue, while “That’s the Way” became The MandalorianThe most famous quote. It seems like a curious contradiction there, because it has become a set of watchwords that people say to each other to express a sense of understanding that dialogue cannot convey elsewhere, relying on its explanatory nature. It’s a catchphrase that rudely sounds like a catchphrase rather than the pseudo-religious mantra you’re supposed to actually feel within the universe.

that makes The MandalorianThe world feels clinical when it shouldn’t — and goes against it star Wars The “live-in” approach that the series absolutely underlines with its aesthetics. It feels like a series of video game levels, such that the characters cease to exist with any form of agency or desire once they dispense their mission dialogue and Dean is on his merry way. In a world already struggling to feel as expansive and vast as a galaxy far, far away as it leans on familiar faces and connections. star WarsIn the past, stilted dialogue isolated every pocket of the characters in it The Mandalorian far from each other.

Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest marvelAnd star WarsAnd Star Trek Releases, what’s next for DC Universe on film and on TVand everything you need to know about the future doctor who.